top of page

Episode 83: Fallen Angel

In recent episodes, we’ve had Josh talk about the killing of Cassie Jo Stoddart in his Scream inspired Patreon mini and Emily’s stories of online dating gone wrong in our episode, “Plenty of Catfish”. I wasn’t searching for a similar story, but I stumbled upon one that eerily resembles a mash-up of both of those cases. This is the story of the murder of Cynthia “CeeCee” Hoffman and the alleged catfish that orchestrated her killing.

Cynthia "CeeCee" Hoffman, photos courtesy of NY Times

Left to right: Kayden McIntosh, 16, Denali Brehmer, 18, and Caleb Leyland, 19, photo courtesy of Anchorage Daily News

Darin Schilmiller, 21 years old, Photo courtesy of Anchorage Daily News

This week’s episode is brought to you by Sinister Coffee and Creamery. Check out the women-owned, small-batch, single-origin, and spooky coffee and creamery by going to Use code MIR10 for 10% off of your order!

CyberScoop - FBI warns of 'large increase' in sextortion attacks, with $8 million in reported losses in 2021 | HuffPost - Alaska Teens Charged With Murder After Fake Millionaire Allegedly Bribed Them | Washington Post - Cynthia Hoffman Murder | CBS News - Alaska Teen Killed Cynthia Hoffman | Alaska News Source - Federal Press Conference Cynthia Hoffman | Alaska News Source - What Happened to CeeCee | Legacy - Cynthia Hoffman Obituary | ADN - Mourners Fill Anchorage Church | Wikitree - Hoffman | Alaska Public - Complaint McIntosh | Indystar - Darin Schilmiller Posing Online Millionaire | Scribd - Darin Schilmiller Court Docs | NBC Chicago - Federal Child Pornography Charges | Alaska News Source - Sixth Person Arrested in Connection | Kvnutalk - Alaska Teen Allegedly Killed Friend | Courtlistener - United States v Schilmiller | ADN - Draft 3 More People Charged | ADN - 2nd Murder Suspect Arrested | Inside Edition - Murder Cynthia Hoffman Woman Known Pal | ABC 57 - Indiana Man Pleads Not Guilty | Alaska News Source - Cynthia Hoffman

460 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page